Click on image for high resolution image. High resolution images may be slow to load and/or incur data charges from your provider. Use your “back” button to return here.
From Past and Present of the City of Lansing, by Albert E. Cowles, 1905.
A paper city, in a part of what is now Lansing, was platted in 1836 by Jerrie and William Ford. The plat was recorded April 19, 1836, and besides the streets, contained sixty-three blocks, divided into 4×8 rod lots, a church square, a public square and an academy square. It took in all of the S.E. 1/4 and the south part of the S.W. 1/4 of Section 21. It was a fine appearing proposition, on paper, calculated to deceive prospective purchasers of the lots who lived so far away that they could not inspect the property and could be induced to rely upon appearances and the statements of the platters and plotters. In this connection, having obtained permission, we will append a statement of the Hon. D. W. Buck, published in the Lansing Journal of November 24, 1904:
Everyone in this city, it is likely, is more or less familiar with stories that have been current from time to time of frauds practiced in connection with the opening up and settlement of the lands of the great west. Not many, however, who have listened to or read such stories are aware that there is in their own city’s history as pretty a tale of deception as adorns the annals of any town or county. The pioneers of Lansing were familiar with the story, and from one of them, Hon. D. W. Buck, whose relatives were actors in the little comedy to be set down, the facts in the brief history of Biddle City were obtained.
In the winter of 1836 tow young men traveled through the town of Lansing, Tompkins county, New York, selling to the farmers lots in Biddle City, which they represented as already well started in the new state, and which was located, they said, at the junction of the Grand and Cedar rivers in Central Michigan. They told of the great forests surrounding the village that needed only to be removed to uncover the richest farming country in the world, and they assured the men of New York who had sons old enough to start for themselves that they need but to send the young men to Biddle City where fortunes in timber and fortunes in land would be found for all.
The Tompkins county farmers became greatly interested; meetings were held- many of them at the home of Daniel Buck, father of D. W. Buck- and finally a stock company was formed out of which sixteen men were chosen to go west and make secure the purchases of the rest.
The long trip was made in the usual way, down the canal, across Lake Huron and so to Detroit, but when the party reached Detroit, however, and inquired the way to Biddle City, no one was found who had ever heard of such a place. The rivers were known, of course, but all the country through which they flowed it was said was a wilderness. Biddle City didn’t exist.
Failing of any information at Detroit the party traveled to Pontiac. There was the same ignorance of Biddle City and the same story of the wilderness told. The men became discouraged; three or four abandoned their comrades and the search; they bought land at Pontiac and their descendants are there to this day.
The remainder of the travelers determined to push on, however, until the rivers on which their town was said to be built were found, soj they hired guides and slowly made their way north and west into Clinton county, and finally when near where DeWitt now stands they found one settler named Scott, who gave them the first news they had obtained of the place they sought. He had heard of Biddle City vaguely, but he told them that west of him there was the home of a settler named William Gilkey who lived near the place where the Cedar empties into the Grand river and he could tell them all there was to tell about Biddle City. Starting once more they traveled to the log cabin of William Gilkey, who was the only settler in all the country round; he lived on what is now known as the Stambaugh place, north of Lansing. He told them what they wished to know.
During the preceding winter, he said, two young men from their own state had stayed with him while on a hunting trip in Michigan. At his house they made their plans to have a town of their own; they platted the ground, staked the lots, named the streets and made ready to sell the town, so beautifully done on paper, to the people whom they expected to interest at home.
Mr. Gilky promised to show the purchasers of those lots the place they were in search of and he did so, taking them through the woods to the point where R. E. Olds’ residence now stands, he pointed across the Cedar to where on the opposite side of the river the low land was lying under water, and he said:
“There, gentlemen, is Biddle City.”
The travelers had not even the satisfaction of feeling that the uncleared land was theirs, for they were told that the site of the city was a part of the princely tract owned by William H. Townsend of New York.
Mr. Gilkey endeavored to prove to them that they need not be cast down even if the town of their hopes had vanished.
“He told them that they saw the greatest country God ever made,” said Mr. Buck in telling the story. He said “land could be bought at ten shillings an acre; and the timber was of the finest quality in the world:” in the end two of them were comforted; Joseph E. North and Daniel Buck elected to invest their money since they had come west for that purpose. Each of the gentlemen bought large tracts of land south of the city; that purchased by Mr. North being known as the “North settlement” at the present time.
The hopes of others of the party were too badly blighted to allow them to remain on the scene of their disappointment. A Mr. Atwood went to what is now Dansville, while Messrs. Townley, Ludlow and others went to Jackson county and the towns of Parma and Tompkins Center bear record in their names that their founders did not forget the homes from which they came.
At that time neither Jackson nor Ingham counties were divided into townships, and when the divisions were finally made the settlers in the former named their township “Tompkins” after their home county as the men who elected to remain near Biddle City called theirs “Lansing,” which eventually gave the name to the city itself.
Biddle City, as platted by the hunters, extended from the junction of the two rivers beyond where the Hugh Lyons factory is now situated. The old Christiancy estate, now owned by Judge R. H. Person, was a part of it and the deeds that passed with that place and others in that vicinity constitute almost the only record of that long vanished paper city.
After making the purchase of their lands, Messrs. Buck and North returned to New York; in 1839 the latter sold his eastern home and came west with his family, eight sons and two daughters. Mr. Buck did not return himself but sent his son Levi, two nephews, Able Miller and Peter Clark, and another young man, Monroe Packard. The three settled upon the lands Mr. Buck had purchased, but Clark was a cabinet maker and could not resist the charms of the magnificent timber; he went to Ionia to settle and practice his trade and his grandchildren still live in that locality.
The immense tracts of land north and south of what is now the city of Lansing were owned by James and Horatio Seymour and William H. Townsend, and the names of Townsend and Seymour streets recall tat fact to memory. But with the visit of the purchasers of lots in Biddle City ends the romance connected with the time, and the history of the location of the capitol and the gradual settling up of the country round is familiar to all and needs not to be rehearsed.
This 1904 “History” of Biddle City was debunked in 2013
Linda R. Peckham, former president of the Historical Society of Greater Lansing and retired English professor from Lansing Community College, and David Votta, researcher and archivist for Capital Area District Library, published a well researched refutation of the land scam story (“Michigan History”, March/April 2013, Daniel Buck’s Biddle City, Peckham & Votta). They claimed that Biddle City was not a land scam. Nor was it the original community of Lansing. It was just a failed, but honest attempt at settlement, on a nearby site, 11 years before the state capital was established by the legislature in 1847.